Refusals & appeals · Section 501
Section 501 Visa Refusal & Cancellation — the Character Test
If the Department has written to you about character under section 501, whether a notice that it intends to refuse or cancel or a decision already made, the deadline to respond or seek review is short and is set by the letter. Keshab Chapagain, registered migration agent (MARN 1576536), prepares the response or the review, on direct retainer or on referral from another agent, from A$3,000 + GST fixed in writing before any work, after a 60-minute consultation at A$550 inc. GST.
By Keshab Chapagain, registered migration agent (MARN 1576536) since 2015 · WIDEN, Sydney · Reviewed November 2026
Keshab Chapagain · MARN 1576536 · Registered since 2015 - ART deadline (s 501, onshore)
- 9 days
- NJL response window
- 14–60 days
- Governing Direction
- Direction 123 from 31 Oct 2026 (Direction 110 before)
The migration agent that other migration agents learn from. WIDEN is an OMARA-approved CPD provider — our training is rated ★4.8 by 40+ registered migration agents.
About the CPD →MARN 1576536 · Verifiable at mara.gov.au
Refused? Get a refusal assessment — before your deadline.
A focused review by a registered migration agent (MARN 1576536) of your refusal decision and your options — why it failed, your realistic prospects at the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART), your deadline, and whether to appeal, re-apply, or stop. Time limits are short and rarely extended, so don't wait. The $330 inc. GST consultation fee is credited toward your engagement fee if you proceed.
What it costs. Refusal assessment $330 inc. GST, credited to your engagement if you proceed. Tribunal (ART) review is from A$6,000 + GST. Your exact fixed fee is set in writing after the assessment, under a service agreement. No outcome can be guaranteed.
Refusal and review deadlines are statutory — don't leave it to the deadline.
⏰ Tight deadlines. Character review timeframes are short — ART review of a s 501 decision is generally 9 days from notification for onshore decisions (longer windows can apply offshore). NJL response windows are typically 14-60 days. Identify the deadline in your decision letter immediately.
Urgent: book the first available time (voice or text, say it is urgent) · Book a consultation →
What is the section 501 character test?
Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 sets out the character test that visa applicants and visa holders must satisfy. A person fails the character test under s 501(6) if any of the following apply, including but not limited to:
- They have a substantial criminal record as defined in s 501(7) — generally a sentence of 12 months or more imprisonment, or cumulative sentences totalling 12 months or more, or a conviction for a sexually based offence involving a child
- They have or have had an association with an individual, group, or organisation involved in criminal conduct
- Having regard to past or present criminal or general conduct, they are not of good character
- There is a risk that, if allowed to enter or remain in Australia, they would engage in criminal conduct, harass or stalk, vilify, or otherwise represent a danger to a segment of the Australian community
- They have been convicted of one or more sexually based offences involving a child
The grounds in s 501(6)(a) to (j) are the gateway. Once one or more grounds are engaged, the decision-maker then considers whether to refuse, cancel, or revoke under the Minister's or delegate's powers.
A character issue in your visa application — before any refusal
Many character matters start earlier than a refusal: a police certificate discloses a conviction, an answer on the application form triggers questions, or the Department sends a request for information or a Natural Justice Letter raising character concerns. At that stage nothing has been decided — and the response you give is often what determines whether the application proceeds or fails. Three things matter most:
- Disclose fully. Non-disclosure is usually worse than the conviction itself — false or misleading answers can trigger refusal under PIC 4020 or cancellation under s 109, independent of the character issue.
- Understand which test applies. Most visas require the applicant to satisfy the character test via Public Interest Criterion 4001; a disclosed offence does not automatically mean failure. Whether a record amounts to a 'substantial criminal record' under s 501(7) is a specific legal threshold, not a vibe.
- Treat the response as submissions. A request about character is answered with evidence and context — sentencing remarks, rehabilitation evidence, references, time elapsed — not a bare admission and hope.
If you are pre-application and worried a record will cause a refusal, that is the cheapest possible time to get advice: the strategy (which visa, what evidence, how to present the history) is set before the Department ever frames the question.
Mandatory vs discretionary decisions
Mandatory cancellation under s 501(3A) applies where the Minister is satisfied the person does not pass the character test because of a substantial criminal record (a sentence of death, life imprisonment or a term of 12 months or more) or a sexually based offence involving a child, and the person is serving a sentence of imprisonment, on a full-time basis in a custodial institution, for an offence against an Australian law (Migration Act s 501(3A), read 18 November 2026). No prior NJL is given before the cancellation; the affected person has a separate, post-decision opportunity to seek revocation by making representations to the Minister under s 501CA.
Discretionary refusal or cancellation under s 501(1), s 501(2), or s 501(3) gives the decision-maker the power — but not the obligation — to refuse or cancel. These decisions are governed by Ministerial Direction 123 for decisions made on or after 31 October 2026, and by Direction 110 for decisions made before that date.
Revocation after mandatory cancellation — s 501CA
A mandatory cancellation under s 501(3A) is not necessarily the end. The affected person is invited to make representations asking the Minister (or delegate) to revoke the cancellation under s 501CA. Representations must be made within 28 days after the person is given the notice and the particulars of the relevant information (Migration Regulations reg 2.52(2)(b), read 18 November 2026).
Revocation representations are effectively a full character case in written form: the decision-maker considers whether the person passes the character test and, if not, whether there is 'another reason' to revoke — assessed against the considerations in the Direction in force on the day of the decision: Direction 123 from 31 October 2026. Because many people in this position are in custody or immigration detention when the clock starts, families often coordinate the response; the quality and evidence of the representations, prepared inside a short window under difficult conditions, largely determine the outcome. A refusal to revoke by a delegate is generally reviewable at the ART within the short s 500 window; a personal decision by the Minister is not.
Direction 123: what decision-makers must consider from 31 October 2026
Direction no. 123 is given under section 499 of the Migration Act. It commences on 31 October 2026 (paragraph 2) and revokes Direction no. 110, which commenced on 21 June 2024, from that date (paragraph 3). The version Home Affairs publishes is a consolidated one that incorporates the amendments made by Direction no. 123A. It applies to decisions under section 501(1), 501(2) and 501CA(4), and defines a decision-maker as a delegate of the Minister or a body such as the Administrative Review Tribunal (paragraph 4). Under section 499(2A) of the Act, decision-makers must comply with a direction made under section 499 (paragraph 5.1(4)). The consolidated version contains no provision keeping Direction 110 in force for matters already under way. Read in full on 20 November 2026.
Primary considerations (paragraph 8), in the order the Direction lists them:
- Protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct
- Whether the conduct engaged in constituted domestic or family violence
- Expectations of the Australian community
- The best interests of minor children in Australia, including the interests of child victims
Other considerations (paragraph 9), which must also be taken into account where relevant and are not limited to these:
- The strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia
- Legal consequences of the decision
- Extent of impediments if removed
How they are weighed (paragraph 7). Protection of the Australian community is generally to be given greater weight than the other primary considerations. Otherwise, primary considerations should generally be given greater weight than the other considerations, and one or more primary considerations may outweigh other primary considerations. Information and evidence from independent and authoritative sources should be given appropriate weight.
What changed from Direction 110. Direction 110 listed five primary considerations, and the strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia was one of them (its paragraph 8). In Direction 123, ties to Australia is the first of the other considerations (paragraph 9.1). Under it the decision-maker must consider the impact on immediate family members in Australia who are citizens, permanent residents or have an indefinite right to remain, and, for cancellation and revocation decisions, how long the person has lived in Australia, any positive contribution to the community and the strength of family or social links. Less weight should generally be given where the person began offending soon after arriving or soon after turning 18.
Rehabilitation and risk. In assessing risk, the decision-maker must have regard to the nature of the harm if the person engaged in further criminal or other serious conduct, and the likelihood of that, taking into account evidence on the risk of re-offending and evidence of rehabilitation achieved by the time of the decision, giving weight to time spent in the community since the most recent offence (paragraph 8.1.2).
The process: NJL → decision → review
1. Natural Justice Letter (NJL)
Before a discretionary refusal or cancellation, the Department generally issues a Natural Justice Letter inviting the affected person to comment and provide submissions on the proposed decision. NJL deadlines are typically 14, 28, or 60 days. The NJL response is the single most important opportunity to influence the outcome at the delegate stage.
2. Delegate decision
A Department delegate makes the decision having regard to the s 501 grounds, the submissions in response to the NJL, and the Direction in force on the day of decision (Direction 123 from 31 October 2026). The decision is communicated in writing with reasons.
3. ART review
A delegate's decision to refuse or cancel a visa under s 501 is reviewable by the Administrative Review Tribunal under s 500 of the Migration Act. The lodgement window is generally 9 days from notification for onshore decisions — significantly shorter than the standard migration review window. Longer windows can apply for some offshore matters. Missing the deadline almost always extinguishes review rights, so the deadline in your decision letter is the priority to identify.
4. Judicial review or ministerial intervention
A negative ART decision (or decisions made personally by the Minister, which are not ART-reviewable) may be challenged in the Federal Court or Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia on legal grounds (jurisdictional error). Section 351 or section 417 ministerial intervention requests may be available in limited circumstances after ART review.
What strong character submissions look like
- Honest engagement with the grounds. The submission addresses each character ground specifically — not generically. If there is a conviction, it is acknowledged and contextualised.
- Evidence of rehabilitation. Where relevant: programs completed, counselling, employment, time since offending, supervision compliance, community references. Documentary evidence, not just assertions.
- Direction 123 mapping. Submissions explicitly address the primary considerations and other considerations, with weight arguments where appropriate.
- Best interests of children evidence. If minor children in Australia are involved, expert reports (psychologist, social worker) on the impact of refusal/cancellation/removal carry significant weight.
- Country information. Where the receiving country has poor conditions or specific risks for the affected person, current country information establishes the impediments.
For migration agents referring matters
Character matters require legal-style submissions, current knowledge of the prevailing Ministerial Direction and recent ART decisions, strict deadline management, and frequently ART or judicial review. This is specialised work that not every migration practice undertakes.
If you are a registered migration agent with a client facing a character refusal, cancellation, or ART review, WIDEN takes these matters on direct referral. The referring agent's relationship with their client is respected — engagement is by written B2B agreement covering scope, fee, and confidentiality (s 35, Migration (Migration Agents Code of Conduct) Regulations 2021). See our For Migration Agents page for the broader B2B framework.
Book about a character matter
Character refusal or cancellation: book the first available time
Review deadlines are statutory and cannot be extended. Bring the decision letter: Keshab Chapagain, registered migration agent (MARN 1576536), reads it with you, tells you whether a review or a fresh application is open and what it costs, before the deadline passes.
What you get
- 30 minutes (A$330) or 60 minutes (A$550) by video with a registered migration agent, Keshab Chapagain, MARN 1576536.
- A written summary of your options and next steps after the session.
- What to bring: The decision letter with its date, the application as lodged, and anything the Department sent before deciding.
- Prefer no call? The written pathway check is done in writing, A$550.
Video consultation, paid when you book, credited in full if you go ahead. WIDEN does not guarantee any outcome. Deadline within 7 days? Book the first time shown and say so in the booking notes.
Related
- For Migration Agents — B2B referral framework for character matters and other specialist work
- Pre-Lodgement Risk Audit — peer RMA second opinion on character responses, NJL drafts, and refusal-recovery applications before submission ($1,500 complex tier, 48-72 hrs)
- Visa refused — start here — deadlines, decision letters, and your realistic options across all refusal types
- Genuine Student Requirement — different test, frequently raised together with character concerns
- Direct contact — for urgent character matters call 02 8188 1887
General information only. This page contains general information about the section 501 character test based on the Migration Act 1958, the Migration Regulations 1994, the current Ministerial Direction, and publicly available Department of Home Affairs and ART guidance. Legislation, Directions, and procedural rules change; the specific version applicable to any individual matter should be confirmed for the date of decision. This page does not constitute migration advice.
Migration advice on character matters is provided by Keshab Chapagain (MARN 1576536) only after a paid initial consultation under section 43 of the Migration (Migration Agents Code of Conduct) Regulations 2021, with a written service agreement issued before further work commences (section 42). The OMARA Consumer Guide is provided to all clients before the consultation begins.
Outcomes. No registered migration agent can guarantee a visa outcome under s 15 of the Code of Conduct. Specific outcomes depend on the decision-maker, the strength of submissions, evidence, and the application of the current Ministerial Direction to the individual circumstances.
Professional indemnity insurance held as required under the Migration Agents Regulations 2026.
Complaints. Consumers have the right to make a complaint about a registered migration agent to the Office of the Migration Agents Registration Authority (OMARA). See our Complaints Policy for the internal process and the OMARA complaint pathway.
Not sure which visa fits you?
Answer three questions. An automated guide points you to the route that usually applies. General information only.
Questions we get asked first
What is the section 501 character test?
Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 sets out the character test that visa applicants and visa holders must satisfy. A person fails the character test if they have a 'substantial criminal record' (typically 12 months or more of cumulative imprisonment, or a single sentence of 12 months or more, or a conviction for a sexually based offence involving a child), have been associated with an organisation involved in criminal conduct, present a risk to the Australian community, or any of the other grounds in s 501(6). The Minister or delegate has both mandatory and discretionary powers to refuse or cancel a visa on character grounds.
What is the difference between a mandatory and discretionary character decision?
Mandatory cancellation under s 501(3A) applies automatically when the visa holder is serving a full-time custodial sentence and either (a) has a substantial criminal record, or (b) has been convicted of a sexually based offence involving a child. Discretionary refusal or cancellation under s 501(1), s 501(2), or s 501(3) gives the Minister or delegate the power to make the decision based on the character test plus the considerations in the current Ministerial Direction.
What is Direction 123?
Direction no. 123 is a direction under section 499 of the Migration Act. It commences on 31 October 2026 and revokes Direction 110 from that date. Its primary considerations are protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct, whether the conduct constituted domestic or family violence, expectations of the Australian community, and the best interests of minor children in Australia. The strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia, a primary consideration under Direction 110, is listed among the other considerations, with legal consequences of the decision and the extent of impediments if removed. Decision-makers, including the Administrative Review Tribunal, must comply with a direction made under section 499. Instrument read 20 November 2026.
What is a Natural Justice Letter (NJL)?
Before a delegate refuses or cancels a visa on character grounds (other than in the s 501(3A) mandatory cancellation context), the affected person is generally given a Natural Justice Letter inviting them to comment on the proposed decision and provide submissions. The NJL specifies the grounds being considered and a deadline for response — often 14, 28, or 60 days depending on the matter. The response is the single most important opportunity to influence the outcome.
Can a character decision be reviewed?
Yes, depending on who made the decision. Delegate decisions are generally reviewable by the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) under s 500 of the Migration Act. The lodgement window is short — typically 9 days for decisions made and notified onshore (and longer windows may apply for decisions notified outside Australia). Decisions made personally by the Minister are not ART-reviewable but may be challenged in the Federal Court or Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia on legal grounds. Ministerial intervention under s 351 or s 417 may also be available in limited circumstances after ART review.
How long do I have to respond to a Natural Justice Letter or lodge an ART appeal?
Time limits are short and strict. NJL response deadlines are typically stated in the letter itself (commonly 14, 28, or 60 days). ART review of a s 501 character decision is generally 9 days from notification for onshore decisions — among the shortest review windows in the migration system — with longer windows possible for some offshore matters. Missing the deadline almost always extinguishes review rights. If you have received a character decision, the priority is to identify the deadline in your decision letter immediately.
Does a past criminal conviction in another country count?
Yes. Section 501(6) and (7) refer to offences regardless of where they occurred. A conviction in your home country can give rise to a 'substantial criminal record' for character purposes. Spent or expired convictions are generally still considered, though the weight given may vary. Honesty about prior convictions in any visa application is critical — providing false or misleading information can itself trigger cancellation under s 109 of the Migration Act, or refusal of a future application under Public Interest Criterion 4020 (bogus documents / false information). Separately, certain visa cancellations engage PIC 4013, which can impose a re-entry exclusion period.
What's the difference between s 501 character cancellation and s 109 cancellation?
Section 501 cancellations are based on the character test (criminal record, association, risk to community). Section 109 cancellations are based on incorrect or misleading information provided in a visa application or to the Department. Both are serious and both can lead to exclusion. Some matters involve both — for example, a visa application that didn't disclose a prior conviction can attract both s 109 (false information) and s 501 (character) consequences.
My visa application has a character issue — will it be refused?
Not automatically. Most visas require the applicant to satisfy the character test (via Public Interest Criterion 4001), and a disclosed conviction does not by itself mean failure — whether a record amounts to a 'substantial criminal record' under s 501(7) is a specific legal threshold. What matters is full disclosure (non-disclosure can trigger PIC 4020 or s 109 consequences that are worse than the conviction) and a properly evidenced response if the Department raises the issue. Pre-application is the cheapest time to get the strategy right.
Can a mandatory s 501(3A) cancellation be revoked?
Yes — the affected person is invited to make representations seeking revocation under s 501CA, typically within 28 days of being given the notice (the invitation states the exact period). The representations are assessed against the character test and the considerations in the current Ministerial Direction. A delegate's refusal to revoke is generally reviewable at the ART within the short s 500 window; a personal decision by the Minister is not ART-reviewable.
Do I need an experienced practitioner to handle a character matter?
Character matters are technically and procedurally distinct from regular visa applications. They involve detailed legal submissions, knowledge of the current Ministerial Direction, careful evidence preparation, strict short deadlines, and frequently ART or judicial review. This is specialised work that not every migration practice undertakes — some agents refer character matters to practitioners who handle them regularly. WIDEN takes character refusals, cancellations, NJL responses, ART lodgements, and ministerial intervention requests, including on referral from other migration agents.
Can WIDEN guarantee a positive outcome on a character matter?
No. Section 15 of the Migration (Migration Agents Code of Conduct) Regulations 2021 prohibits any registered migration agent from guaranteeing visa outcomes. What WIDEN can do is review the matter against Direction 123, identify the strongest available submissions, prepare the evidence package, lodge ART or ministerial intervention requests where appropriate, and represent the applicant through the process — all under a written service agreement issued after a paid consultation.
Keep reading